34 replies to this topic

[Dustin]

Sorry I don't have a source for this, but it was on Inside the NFL.

 

He was basically telling the team on his last drive that they needed to get into field goal range before the "second coin-flip".

 

Just thought this would show his motivation for trying to force the ball with under a minute left in the quarter.

[Dustin]

Refs did a poor job of explaining the overtime rules to be honest.

[coltsrule91]

ive never heard of that. i always thought in the playoffs it keeps going until the game is decided

[Nobody]

I thought that too.

[braveheartcolt]

Worst excuse of the year. How we all ripped McNabb a few years ago. Do not blame the refs for this piece of junk.

[Nobody]

Worst excuse of the year. How we all ripped McNabb a few years ago. Do not blame the refs for this piece of junk.

McNabb didn't know that there is only 1 OT in a regular season game.

Peyton didn't know a very obscure rule. When was the last 2OT game in the NFL?

[Gavin]

He is supposed to know the rule and they were near the 50 yard line with two timeouts left if nothing was there he should have thrown the ball away, just a bad decision on his part to throw the ball in that situation its that simple

[braveheartcolt]

McNabb didn't know that there is only 1 OT in a regular season game.

Peyton didn't know a very obscure rule. When was the last 2OT game in the NFL?

Wait a minute, is this not the most studious man in the NFL...EVER? He blew it, we all know that, and felt his pain. But this is just ridiculous.

[bayone]

He is supposed to know the rule and they were near the 50 yard line with two timeouts left if nothing was there he should have thrown the ball away, just a bad decision on his part to throw the ball in that situation its that simple

 

 

stokley was wide open with a good 25 yards of Yac possible ,, peyton threw across body in reg season to stockley when flushed to right sideline & got a td

 

It was a bad decision as he didnt have the arm strength to throw over the defender  to a wide open stockley so throw was quite poor & underthrown 

[bayone]

Sorry I don't have a source for this, but it was on Inside the NFL.

 

He was basically telling the team on his last drive that they needed to get into field goal range before the "second coin-flip".

 

Just thought this would show his motivation for trying to force the ball with under a minute left in the quarter.

 

stokley was wide open with a good 25 yards of Yac possible ,, peyton threw across body in reg season to stockley when flushed to right sideline & got a td

 

It was a bad decision as he didnt have the arm strength to throw over the defender  to a wide open stockley so throw was quite poor & underthrown 

[Yehoodi]

McNabb didn't know that there is only 1 OT in a regular season game.

Peyton didn't know a very obscure rule. When was the last 2OT game in the NFL?

yes it is a rare occurance, but the ref stated at the start of OT that we are starting a new game and the only difference is that first to score rule and that all replays are upstairs . . . otherwise is a new game . . . it understandable that the Broncos were in some degree of shock, after just yielding a game tying TD, and one may not be listening to everything another is saying . . .

It is always refreshing to see an individual being honest like PM was with his comments and the same goes for McNabb . . . I always tip my tap to people who are honest even if they may take a little ribbing for it . . .

[BrentMc11]

I can honestly say that I thought there was a coin flip at the second OT.  I guess it was the first time I had seen it happen.....OK, I had to say I was wrong for anyone who thought I was incapable of admitting my mistakes!!!!

[Dustin]

Worst excuse of the year. How we all ripped McNabb a few years ago. Do not blame the refs for this piece of junk.

 

How is this an excuse? Reading comprehension bro, do you have it? I just stated that that's why he was trying to force the throw. I didn't say it was a bad throw or that it wasn't a bad decision. Just giving insight to why he was trying to fit passes into such tight windows that drive.

[tonychen]

Worst excuse of the year. How we all ripped McNabb a few years ago. Do not blame the refs for this piece of junk.

 

Well said. Hard to imagine Manning could make this kind of mistake but rules are changing, they need to keep up with it.

[tonychen]

How is this an excuse? Reading comprehension bro, do you have it? I just stated that that's why he was trying to force the throw. I didn't say it was a bad throw or that it wasn't a bad decision. Just giving insight to why he was trying to fit passes into such tight windows that drive.

 

If he thought there was another coin flip, it made perfect sense to try that pass since even if the ball got int the first OT could be over and it might not matter. Really hope somebody can confirm with Peyton.

[Thewholefnshow28]

The funny thing is if this was anyone but Luck or Manning this board would be laughing and making fun of him and receive the same reaction McNabb got.

Overtime has always been another game the only difference was before it was sudden death and you just kept going like a regular game until someone scored. Now you have the new rules. This is not some obscure rule that has never been used before.

[Dustin]

The funny thing is if this was anyone but Luck or Manning this board would be laughing and making fun of him and receive the same reaction McNabb got.

Overtime has always been another game the only difference was before it was sudden death and you just kept going like a regular game until someone scored. Now you have the new rules. This is not some obscure rule that has never been used before.

 

There's only been like 6 double OTs in history. That's pretty obscure.

[Gavin]

stokley was wide open with a good 25 yards of Yac possible ,, peyton threw across body in reg season to stockley when flushed to right sideline & got a td

 

It was a bad decision as he didnt have the arm strength to throw over the defender  to a wide open stockley so throw was quite poor & underthrown 

Thats who that was! Stokley, it happened so fast and cameras barely caught Stokley while Manning was scrambling, but when I saw it I thought he was WIDE open 

[Gavin]

There's only been like 6 double OTs in history. That's pretty obscure when the last one happened like 9 years ago.

2004 between Panthers and Rams, The rule was not explained well by the ref but I would think Manning new the rule but if he says he didn't I guess he didn't either way he had plenty of time to move the ball downfield with 2 timeouts and very close to the 50 yard line (within a couple yards) he just rushed and tried to do to much, sometimes it works out, other times ya get what happened in that game

[jvan1973]

The funny thing is if this was anyone but Luck or Manning this board would be laughing and making fun of him and receive the same reaction McNabb got.

Overtime has always been another game the only difference was before it was sudden death and you just kept going like a regular game until someone scored. Now you have the new rules. This is not some obscure rule that has never been used before.

How many double ot games have there been in the history of the nfl

[Dustin]

This coming from a guy who thinks the residents of Indiana have a say in day to day operations of the colts organization..

 

Something something Julian Edelman something.

[Dustin]

This "primadonna" also led the team to unprecedented success in franchise history, 2 Super Bowl appearances and 1 Lombardi trophy. Yeah, what a hack!

 

We would have gone to 4 if we had Julian Edelman!!

[No 1 Manning Fan]

I am disappointed that one of the most studious QBs in the game doesn't know OT rules. Oh well, nothing like a season ending mistake to serve as a learning experience.

[bayone]

This "primadonna" also led the team to unprecedented success in franchise history, 2 Super Bowl appearances and 1 Lombardi trophy. Yeah, what a hack!

 

& could have been more with better coaching and an all around team , its a team game

 

Colts have learned lesson, new staff will provide proper offensive & defensive balance noit relying on someont to always get a lead and then tree off on QB's to proitect it

 

if that was the case why does peyton have the most 4th qrtr comebacks in history

[oldunclemark]

Dustin....

If he thought there would be a second coin flip....

..wouldnt that make him more careful...Denver could have won the second coin flip..


..and the last pass wasn't careless....Manning threw a TD on a similar play 3 weeks earlier..

... ...Stokley was open....Peyton just threw the ball very badly..

..and to be honest..I didnt know there wasn't a coin flip either...In the regular season there is only one OT

I havnet seen a double overtime NFL game in a couple of decades...

[Dustin]

Remember the thumbs up/thumbs down thing? Good times.

[No 1 Manning Fan]

& could have been more with better coaching and an all around team , its a team game

 

Colts have learned lesson, new staff will provide proper offensive & defensive balance noit relying on someont to always get a lead and then tree off on QB's to proitect it

 

if that was the case why does peyton have the most 4th qrtr comebacks in history

Why people put all of the praise OR all of the blame on Peyton is beyond me. Look at Tom Brady. When the Pats had a balanced team, he won 3 Super Bowls. Since then, he has played lights out and led one of the best offenses in league history, but has fallen short of winning another trophy because the Pats' defense has declined. Are we all going to blame Brady and call him a hack? No. He has been better since the Super Bowl years, but it takes balance on both sides of the ball.

[oldunclemark]

How many people here were SURE there wasnt a kickoff at the start of the second OT...

I wasnt

[Dustin]

How many people here were SURE there wasnt a kickoff at the start of the second OT...

I wasnt

 

I thought there would be another kick-off as well.

[jvan1973]

How many people here were SURE there wasnt a kickoff at the start of the second OT...

I wasnt

I had no idea honestly. But after the pick i was hoping

[shakedownstreet]

how many times has peyton manning gone through an overtime period without getting his team in position to score ...??

 

when san fran/st louis tied, i said that's what happens when you don't have an elite qb. wasn't that smith's last game as the starter?

[No 1 Manning Fan]

He is supposed to know the rule and they were near the 50 yard line with two timeouts left if nothing was there he should have thrown the ball away, just a bad decision on his part to throw the ball in that situation its that simple

Yes it was. You're right. The bottom line is he shouldn't have thrown that ball. You never throw back across your body when running the opposite direction. Physics is against you. His momentum was going to his right, therefore the momentum of the ball was going to his right. Throwing the opposite way severely reduced the velocity the ball had when it left his hand. Bad technique and bad decision.

[braveheartcolt]

How many people here were SURE there wasnt a kickoff at the start of the second OT...

I wasnt

Good point, although I don't think any of us are paid $20m a year to know.....

[oldunclemark]

Good point, although I don't think any of us are paid $20m a year to know.....

Very true.....but had anyone on the field ever played or coached in a double overtime game...?

(and I know that's a near impossible question to answer)

[Fx Stryker]

I thought there was a coin flip/kickoff for the second OT.