15 replies to this topic

[danlhart87]

South
1. Brees
2. Ryan
3. Newton
4. Freeman

North
1. Rodgers
2. Stafford
3. Cutler
4. Ponder

West
1. Wilson
2. Colin K
3. Bradford
4. Kolb

East
1. Manning
2. Griffin III
3. Romo
4. Foles

Top 5
1. Rodgers
2. Brees
3. Manning
4. Stafford
5. Ryan

[Bogie]

South

1. Brees

2. Newton

3. Freeman

4. Ryan

 

North

1. Rodgers

2. Stafford

3. Ponder

4. Cutler

 

East

1. Romo

2. Griffin

3. Manning

4. Dog Killer

 

West

1. Kapernick

2. Bradford

3. Wilson

4. Kolb

 

 

Top 5

1. Rodgers

2. Brees

3. Stafford

4. Newton

5. Griffin

[Dustin]

NFC South: Brees, Ryan, Newton, Freeman

NFC East: RG3, Romo, Manning, Vick/Foles

NFC North: Rodgers, Stafford, Cutler, Ponder.............................Joe Webb

NFC West: Kap, Wilson, Bradford, Kolb

 

Top 5: Rodgers, Brees, Ryan, Stafford, RG3

[jvan1973]

NFC South: Brees, Ryan, Newton, Freeman
NFC East: RG3, Romo, Manning, Vick/Foles
NFC North: Rodgers, Stafford, Cutler, Ponder.............................Joe Webb
NFC West: Kap, Wilson, Bradford, Kolb

Top 5: Rodgers, Brees, Ryan, Stafford, RG3

Your east ranking is comical

[Gavin]

NFC East

1.Manning

2.Romo

3.Griffin III

4.Vick

 

 

NFC North

1.Rodgers

2.Stafford

3.Cutler

4.Ponder

 

NFC South

1.Brees

2.Ryan

3.Freeman

4.Newton

 

NFC West

1.Wilson

2.Bradford

3.Kevin Kolb

4.Kaepernick (I need to see more from him before I flip him and Kolb, Kolb has no O Line)

 

 

Top 5 all around both conferences

 

1.Manning

2.Brady

3.Brees

4.Rodgers

5.Eli Manning 

[Dustin]

Your east ranking is comical

 

Your right, I'd switch Romo and Manning. Don't know what I was thinking there.

 

EDIT: Wait isn't this based off of the regular season?

[jvan1973]

Your right, I'd switch Romo and Manning. Don't know what I was thinking there.

EDIT: Wait isn't this based off of the regular season?

What ever its based on doesn't equal a two time super bowl mvp being behind a rookie who couldn't finish the season

[Dustin]

What ever its based on doesn't equal a two time super bowl mvp being behind a rookie who couldn't finish the season

If its based on this season it does. Manning played terrible and RG3 had a 104 passer rating. Eli didn't even make the playoffs.

[jvan1973]

If its based on this season it does. Manning played terrible and RG3 had a 104 passer rating. Eli didn't even make the playoffs.

then how do you have brees above Ryan

[Dustin]

then how do you have brees above Ryan

 

Because I just don't take into account wins. Brees threw for 5000 yards and 40 TDs with no run game and the worst defense in NFL history.

[Bogie]

Because I just don't take into account wins. Brees threw for 5000 yards and 40 TDs with no run game and the worst defense in NFL history.

 

 

He has a ring. Ryan is 0-4 in the playoffs.

[Dustin]

He has a ring. Ryan is 0-4 in the playoffs.

 

Umm, I have Brees ranked above Ryan. Not sure what you're trying to say here.

[Vance]

South

1. Brees

2. Newton

3. Freeman

4. Ryan

 

 

LOL?!

[BodaciousBryce]

Assuming just talking about this year

 

South

1. Brees

2. Ryan

3. Newton

4. Freeman

 

North

1. Rodgers

2. Stafford

3. Cutler

4. Ponder

 

West

1. Wilson

2. Colin K

3. Bradford

4. Kolb 

 

East

1. Griffin III

2. Manning

3. Romo

4. Foles 

 

Top 5

1. Brees

2. Rodgers

3. Ryan

4. Russel Wilson

5. Robert Griffin III

[Vltrophy1]

South
1. Brees
2. Ryan
3. Newton
4. Freeman
North
1. Rodgers
2. Stafford
3. Cutler
4. Ponder
West
1. Wilson
2. Colin K
3. Bradford
4. Kolb
East
1. Manning
2. Griffin III
3. Romo
4. Foles
Top 5
1. Rodgers
2. Brees
3. Manning
4. Stafford
5. Ryan
I would have to agree w/all ur listings.

[Vltrophy1]

then how do you have brees above Ryan you can't just base it on this season alone. How are you going to take away the hard work & dedication it took to win the SB? It's about what they've done in their career. Ryan is a good QB but has 0 wins in post season. Peyton's post season stats aren't great but he's proved himself. The only thing Ryan has proved is that he can loose in the playoffs